In this section

Dr Johnny Roughan and Professor Paul Flecknell, Newcastle University

Assessing the welfare of mice used in cancer research

Abstract of research

Cancer research in the UK involves nearly 400,000 animals per year, of which 96% are mice. Many of these develop tumours that are assumed to cause pain and/or distress, so guidelines have been developed with the aim of removing animals from studies before any suffering occurs. However, these guidelines do not include objective assessments of animal welfare. This project aims to determine which cancer models cause the most pain and at what stage of tumour development it occurs. This could result in certain tumour types being avoided and, where this is not possible, the development of more relevant guidelines for refining humane endpoints.

Although previous NC3Rs funded work indicated that mice with bladder cancer experienced pain, individual variations in tumour growth rate made it impossible to refine endpoints. This new research will more accurately establish the relationship between cancer development and the onset of pain in three common mouse cancer models. The project will determine whether new methodologies can be used to assess the subjective experiences of mice with cancer and whether current endpoint estimates are appropriate. The methods used to determine whether mice feel cancer pain will be the conditioned place preference paradigm (CPP) and conditional drug discrimination. In CPP, if the mouse shows a preference for an environment where they were previously exposed to an analgesic (e.g. morphine), and that preference increases over time, it can be inferred that they feel more pain as the tumour develops. In the drug discrimination studies, mice are given either an analgesic or placebo and perform a task to obtain a food reward. Changes in task success rate can then be used to monitor whether they are feeling pain.

These measures of the subjective state of the animal will then be correlated with changes in behaviour, peripheral sensitisation, and measures of tumour growth to give a clearer picture of pain caused by different tumour types. More broadly this work will establish new methods for assessing the welfare consequences of other potentially painful procedures applied to laboratory rodents.